
Let's take a vote, Gossip Girl fans. Who think's Hairspray star, Brittany Snow, is a good choice to play the teenage Lily Van Der Woodsen in the upcoming Gossip Girl spinoff?
Here's our pro/con list to help you decide:
Pro: Inexplicably, we always find ourselves endeared to anyone who's been on a show with Joey Lawrence.
Con: Her John Tucker Must Die romance with Penn Badgley takes on a weirdly Oedipal quality:

Pro: Her freakishly long toes lend themselves to unusual sexploits of which we can easily believe Lily capable...
Con: We don't really picture the teenage Lily with a Minnie Mouse voice.
Pro: There's a possibility (albeit remote) that Vin Diesel will make a guest appearance...

Previously:
The Gossip Girl Spinoff Will Be Set In the 80's?