Hallmark Gay Marriage Cards: Political Heroism Or Plain Greed?

Posted by Brian Fairbanks

We understand Hallmark is a business-- in the entertainment business, if you will. That's why we almost understood their use of the word "queer" as a punchline in a greeting card (it actually wasn't as bad as all that.) But are their latest wedding cards cynical, because they waited for the cultural tide to turn in favor of gay marriage before they had the guts to mass produce them?

Here's the full photo ABC News has of the card due out soon:

For those of you with eyes even worse than ours, the card reads: "Two hearts. One promise." Hell, we wouldn't be surprised if people walk past it in the greeting card aisle without even picking up on the fact that both cover characters are wearing tuxedos. Of course, this doesn't mean Hallmark has been able to slip this one past the crazies at the American Family Association, which pressed "SEND" on their instant, fill-in-the-company-name boycott press release fax machine:

Hallmark Greeting Cards has announced it will begin selling same-sex wedding cards, even though same-sex marriage is legal in only two states. The purpose, they say, is to satisfy consumer demand. It appears that their purpose is also to push same-sex marriage. Last year Hallmark began offering "coming out" cards - as in "coming out of the closet" -- a euphemism for announcing homosexuality.

We've all given or received Hallmark Cards – remember their slogan – "when you care enough to send the very best." But promoting same-sex marriage for profit is not the very best for families or our nation.
[If you're looking for a link, sorry, we don't give out page views to hate sites - Ed.]

As various media outlets have already pointed out, the Hallmark cards are a step forward but also not even offensive to gay marriage opponents-- after all, the language is neutral, meaning there's no mention of "marriage" or even "gay butt sex." For all the AFA knows, these cards are for "commitment ceremonies," which probably wouldn't shut them up but maybe would keep a boycott from succeeding.

What do you think? Should Hallmark be praised or condemned for these cards?

Image via ABC.

 

Related:

This Week In Gayness: Man Gets 150 Days For Being Accessory To Gay Murder

While You Were Sleeping: The Madonna-Guy Ritchie Separation

Doctors Shocked To Learn They Can't Reject Gay Patients


Comments

Bram said:

Not greed, not political, just business as usual. And with two states now having legal gay marriage and the "cultural tide to turn in favor", a market that's become big enough to justify the expense (and hassle from people like the AFA). So neither praise not condemnation for a business that is doing that which businesses do, satisfy (and possibly create) a demand in the market for products and services.

August 25, 2008 11:09 AM

dippy_gumball said:

There's a need.  They filled it.  That's greedy?  No.

It's wonderful :)

August 25, 2008 12:11 PM

farknerve said:

As far as Hallmark itself, it's just business as usual, so it's neutral.  Culturally, though, I think it's a positive thing.  Corporate greed has been a major factor in promoting the gay rights movement -- part of the reason tides DID turn in favor of gay marriage was because Americans were exposed to Will & Grace, Queer Eye for the Straight Guy, etc.  

August 25, 2008 2:39 PM

Bob Zuley said:

Commended, of course.  Gay marriage is an inevitability, and we shant allow the religious zealots to deny us acceptance and equality.  There is a tremendous amount of effort wasted in a futile drive to what end, exactly?  Promoting hate?  Good-hearted people will still be good-hearted irregardless of religious fealty.  But scripture provides those dark of heart a means and mechanism to practice exclusion and hatred, all in the name of magical thinking.  That Florida principal who denigrated the lesbian student is but the latest example.  Let us hope that Obama will be a fact-based president and not another faith-based sentinel of fear, ignorance, and hate.

August 25, 2008 4:37 PM

About Brian Fairbanks

Brian Fairbanks, the Senior National Political Correspondent for Nerve, is a filmmaker living in Brooklyn or New Orleans, depending on the season. He is a heavily-armed advocate of gun control.

in